 Attorney John Musca
From The Florida DUI Forums
-
Florida DUI Issues
Are there any current issues in Florida DUI cases that are resulting in chemical evidence, either breath or blood, being thrown out of court? Who are...
-
Pamama City DUI legal advice about courts, lawyers and attorneys
What court do DUI charges from Panama City Florida go to? What are your experiences there?
If you are convicted of drunk driving in Panama City,...
-
Palmetto DUI legal advice about court, lawyers and attorneys
What court do DUI charges from Palmetto Florida go to? What are your experiences there?
If you are convicted of drunk driving in Palmetto, what...
-
Palm Harbor DUI legal advice about attorneys, lawyers and court
What court do DUI charges from Palm Harbor Florida go to? What are your experiences there?
If you are convicted of drunk driving in Palm Harbor,...
-
Palm Coast DUI legal advice about lawyers, attorneys and court
What court do DUI charges from Palm Coast Florida go to? What are your experiences there?
If you are convicted of drunk driving in Palm Coast,...
-
Palm Beach Gardens DUI legal advice about courts, lawyers and attorneys
What court do DUI charges from Palm Beach Gardens Florida go to? What are your experiences there?
If you are convicted of drunk driving in Palm...
-
Palm Beach DUI legal advice about court, lawyers and attorneys
What court do DUI charges from Palm Beach Florida go to? What are your experiences there?
If you are convicted of drunk driving in Palm Beach,...
-
Palm Bay DUI legal advice about court, lawyers and attorneys
What court do DUI charges from Palm Bay Florida go to? What are your experiences there?
If you are convicted of drunk driving in Palm Bay, what...
-
Palatka DUI legal advice about court, lawyers and attorneys
What court do DUI charges from Palatka Florida go to? What are your experiences there?
If you are convicted of drunk driving in Palatka, what can...
-
Pahokee DUI legal advice about court, lawyers and attorneys
What court do DUI charges from Pahokee Florida go to? What are your experiences there?
If you are convicted of drunk driving in Pahokee, what can...
|
|
|
Below is a sample list of possible challenges in a DUI case. Remember, however, that each case is unique. Your attorney will establish which of the many challenges below apply to you after a careful review of the facts and circumstances surrounding your particular case.
Motions To Dismiss (generally):
- Officer did not have a valid reason to pull you over (for example, weaving inside your lane is not enough to justify a stop in Florida)
- Initial stop was made as a result of uncorroborated information supplied by an unreliable civilian witness
- Officer did not have enough probable cause to detain and/or arrest you.
- Prosecution cannot establish the required element that you were the driver of the vehicle or that you were in actual physical control (no wheel witness)
- Violation of right to counsel
- Officer interfered or did not make a reasonable effort to provide you with the right to obtain an independent blood test.
- Prosecutor did not timely file - Statute of limitations expired
- Defective charging document
- Facts are insufficient to support a finding of guilt beyond a reasonable doubt of all elements necessary to convict for DUI
- Violation of speedy trial right
Motions to Suppress Evidence (generally):
- Suppression of statements for violation of 5th Amendment Miranda rights
- Supression of field sobriety exercises for failure to obtain voluntary consent (coercion)
- Suppression of refusal to submit to field sobriety tests
- Suppression of the results of the HGN test (eye test) as it was not administered by a certified drug recognition expert
- Suppression of all evidence gathered after your right to counsel attached and the officer failed to advise you of that right
- Suppression of the evidentiary breath/blood/urine test on the grounds the officer failed to properly advise you of the implied consent warnings
- Suppression of the evidentiary breath/blood test on the grounds you expressed confusion regarding the implied consent warnings and the officer failed to clarify those warnings (Confusion doctrine)
- Suppression of the evidentiary breath/blood/urine test on the failure of the officer interfering with your right to obtain an independent blood test
Florida DUI Breath Test Challenges:
- The breath test was improperly administered
- The breath test operator was not certified
- The machine was broken or malfunctioning
- The 20 minute observation period was not adhered to
- Human factors interfered
- You had something in your mouth prior to or during testing
- Failure to conduct another observation period after an invalid sample
- Radio frequency interference
- Elevated body temperature produced invalid results
- The presence of acetone skewed the results (such as if you are a diabetic)
- Failure to provide maitnenance documents (discovery violation)
Florida Blood Test Challenges:
- The phlebotomist was not trained properly
- A breath test was not impracticable or impossible under the circumstances and no accident causing serious bodily injury occured
- Proper blood draw procedures were not followed
- Defects in the chain of custody
- Tainted or contaminated sample
- Failure to properly preserve or store sample
- The prosecutor cannot prove that the sample of blood is yours
|
|
|